.svg)
.svg)
Search
Retained executive search is an exclusive engagement in which a food and beverage company pays a search firm in staged installments to fill one critical leadership role, with the firm accountable until the seat is filled. In 2026, brands use it because the leaders they want are employed, guarded, and being courted by everyone else.
Look at the churn first. Among the world’s 50 largest consumer products companies, 15 named new CEOs in 2025, a 30% turnover rate against 12% for the S&P 500, per Spencer Stuart’s analysis of the sector. Across the S&P 1500, 168 companies installed new CEOs, the most since 2010, and 84% of them were first-timers. The leadership market in food and beverage is moving faster than the org charts underneath it.
What is retained executive search in food and beverage?
One client, one firm, one role, worked to completion. The client typically pays a third of the fee at engagement, a third at candidate interviews, and a third at offer acceptance, which funds dedicated research, sourcing, and assessment on that single search. Protis Global has run this model in consumer products since 1995, across more than 3,000 placements, and backs C-suite placements with a 180-day replacement guarantee against the 90 days most firms offer.
The mechanics matter because of who you are trying to reach. The commercial leader growing a functional beverage brand did not post a resume anywhere.
Why does 2026 demand a different hiring approach?
Because the category map is being redrawn, and talent is migrating across it.
|
Category |
What the data says |
Source |
|---|---|---|
|
Non-alcoholic beer |
+111% volume 2021–2025; now 2.5% of beer volume |
|
|
Energy drinks |
$28.1B, up 15.2% |
|
|
RTD cocktails |
Over 12% of total alcohol dollars |
|
|
Zero-sugar CSDs |
+11.8% in 2025 to $19.3B |
|
|
Craft beer |
Production down 4% in 2025; 481 closures vs 300 openings |
|
|
Full-calorie cola |
Down 8% in 2025 |
Every row of that table is a career decision someone is making right now. We interview senior operators in declining segments who want out and executives in hot segments fielding three approaches a month. In our searches this summer, a large beverage strategic restructuring after a string of functional-brand acquisitions put director and VP talent on the market within weeks. Firms that map these movements daily know which leaders transfer across categories and which ones only look like they would.
Growth is also coming from below. McKinsey’s 2026 State of Food and Beverage analysis found brands under $100M in revenue drove 35% of category growth in 2025, up from 15% in 2021. Those companies need leaders who can run a P&L without a big-company support system, and that filter eliminates more impressive resumes than any other single criterion we apply.
What does the retained search process look like in practice?
An intake meeting sets the candidate profile, comp parameters, and interview plan. Then the cadence starts: we commit to presenting at least one qualified candidate by the second weekly review meeting, and we post notes to a live pipeline the client can see within 24 hours of every candidate interaction. Weekly 30-minute reviews with the hiring manager have replaced the old model of a formal update every few weeks, because feedback loops are where searches go to die.
Assessment runs deeper than interviews. Candidates complete a psychometric assessment before the first hiring-manager conversation, and our Personal Scorecard process maps what would make each one move and stay: remit, trajectory, family, money, in that order more often than clients expect. One current example of the model at full stretch: an international snack manufacturer entering the US retained us for its first American CEO, profile set at 10 to 15 years in CPG with P&L experience in the $100M range, timed so the leader arrives before the new plant does.
Persistence is part of the product. On one long-running search, the breakthrough came from systematically re-approaching candidates who had said no months earlier, because circumstances change and 250 mapped profiles are an asset, not a graveyard.
What should you ask a search firm before retaining one?
Ask for category placements by name and year. Ask who does the actual sourcing and where. Ask what happens in week two if you have seen zero candidates. Ask for the replacement guarantee in writing. And ask how the firm assesses motivation, because a firm that cannot answer that question is planning to lose your finalist to a counteroffer. Diversity outcomes tell you about process quality too: 48% of Protis Global placements are diversity hires, which reflects full market maps rather than recycled shortlists.
FAQ
What does retained executive search cost for a food and beverage company? Typically 25 to 33% of first-year cash compensation, paid in thirds tied to search milestones. Some firms, including ours, structure an additional indirect fee for C-suite work and back it with a 180-day replacement guarantee.
How is retained search different from contingency recruiting? A retained firm is paid to complete your search and works it exclusively. Contingency recruiters are paid only on placement, so effort flows to whichever open role across their desk closes fastest.
Can a retained search be run confidentially? Yes. Replacements and market-entry hires run confidential as a matter of routine. Candidates learn the company’s name only after screening.
Which roles justify retained search in food and beverage? CEO, CFO, COO, and CCO seats, plus VP-level sales, marketing, operations, and supply chain roles where a vacancy compounds weekly and the target candidates are all employed.
Hiring a leader into this market? Start at I Need Talent.
